Are metal-based antibacterial gels a potential alternative for disinfection in contemporary endodontics?

A Commentary on

Berri M E, Jerez-Olate C, Ramírez J A et al.

Novel Antibacterial and Biocompatible Nanostructured Gels Based on One-step Synthesis as a Potential Disinfectant for Endodontic Infection Control. J Endod 2024; 50: 74–84.

GRADE Rating:

Commentary

Effective chemomechanical disinfection lies at the core of endodontic principles for success. The complex anatomy of the root canal system, within which microbial infection exists in a biofilm, means the chemical component of this approach is critical1,2. Common antimicrobial irrigant solutions available on the market today include sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl), citric acid, EDTA, and chlorohexidine. These may be supplemented through interappointment dressings, such as calcium hydroxide (CH), where the bactericidal medicament is left in between visits. At present, there is no ‘ideal’ method that can completely and safely disinfect the root canal system, with eradication of all microorganisms and dissolution of necrotic organic debris3. The limitations of existing disinfectants and dressings has driven research into seeking for alternative methods. Although NaOCl remains the gold standard irrigant, recent publications have identified the potential effectiveness of metal nanoparticles, due to their inherent antimicrobial properties. However, the applications, and use of, different metals in endodontics have not been thoroughly explored to-date4.

The introduction of this paper5 demonstrated compelling arguments in favour of introducing a new method for achieving intracanal disinfection, with consideration of contemporary treatments. Interestingly, the authors did not commit their novel gel to use as either an irrigant solution, or interappointment dressing, highlighting the general levels of uncertainty around the clinical application of these gels.

In total, seven different in vitro methods were used in this study, including: atomic force microscopy (AFM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), transmission electron microscopy (TEM), energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDS), Rheometery, confocal microscopy, and fluorescence microscopy. Methods were not always clearly aligned with objectives of the study, with the relevance of some methods to the overall aim being unclear.

As part of the study design, the control group utilised polymers without metal nanoparticles. However, it may have been even more informative to include other well-established methods of chemical disinfection, such as NaOCl and/or CH. This would have increased the external validity of the study, considering they are already an established part of clinical practice. It was noted that both products were included in the later sections, when investigating the anti-bacterial properties. However, the authors did not make it clear why these products were not universally tested in all experiments.

The results of all experiments were mostly reported, including detailed tables and high-quality pictures that were well presented and easy to interpret. One of the in vitro methods (EDS) was mentioned earlier in the text under the methods section, but then the results were not presented. Much of the data were qualitative, where the findings should be interpreted with caution as blinding did not occur, risking operator bias. It may have been possible to obtain more quantitative data in some experiments. For example, the AFM is well-known to provide mechanical information at nanoscale, which would have been an ideal method design for this experiment to test the gels modulus of elasticity, viscoelastic, and/or hardness properties. It was noted that a rheometer was used to test the fluid dynamics and mechanical properties, which would have been interesting to compare with the AFM findings.

The results section highlighted that cytotoxicity testing methods were not compatible with most gel compositions, which dissolved upon contact with the cell cultures. Antimicrobial comparisons with sodium hypochlorite demonstrated that the gels were significantly less effective against E. Faecalis, after short a 1-h exposure, whereas longer exposures (7-days) had a comparable outcome with CH. Direct comparisons were not possible as each product was tested differently, the reasons of which are unclear.

A limitation of this study is the lack of comparison of most experiments to a control group. Only the roughness levels, antibacterial and cytotoxicity levels were compared to the experimental gel groups. This reinforced the need to justify each testing method in line with the aims of the study.

The discussion explored all the most relevant findings, with reference to the original aim of the paper. The authors explored ways to improve their current gel formulations for future research. In particular, it was clear that the gel was highly viscous, which is not an ideal property for disinfection considering the complex anatomy of root canal systems and the ability of bacteria to penetrate dentinal tubules. It was discussed that a successful balance of minimising cytotoxicity whilst maintaining anti-microbial properties had been achieved in this experiment. However, the results reported that the toxicity levels could not be confirmed for the majority of experimental groups. Furthermore, NaOH was significantly more effective against E. Faecalis than all gel formulations. Although, limited findings showed that copper-based gel appeared to be more effective in both areas compared to silver ions. Therefore, it could be argued that the aim for this study was broadly met. Authors also acknowledged what they considered as the main limitation of this experiment, where they only tested each gel against a single bacterial species (E. Faecalis). Although, this was inherent issue associated with the laboratory-based design, which cannot mimic all relevant in vivo environmental conditions.

Limitations

In addition to the above comments, a further limitation was the exclusion of either human teeth, or standardised 3 d models of human root canal systems. AFM could have also tested for mechanical changes to the root dentine post-exposure, as this was a key factor not considered in this study, and essential to the long-term prognosis. It is widely reported that irrigants and dressings may damage dentine, increasing the risk of fracture and impacting sealing of the root canal system.

Summary

This study presents an alternative approach for managing root canal disinfection utilising a novel antibacterial gel, infused with metal nanoparticles (silver or copper). Although, this study has highlighted that development is still in the very early stages, and much additional research is needed to ensure that this is a safe and effective alternative to current practices. It is unclear what role exactly these gels would form as part of the endodontic armamentarium, e.g., irrigant or medicament between visits. This question is something that would be addressed at a later stage once other aspects have become clear, such as the flowability and the effects on dentine’s mechanical properties.

Related Articles

An artificial market model for the forex market

As financial markets have transitioned toward electronic trading, there has been a corresponding increase in the number of algorithmic strategies and degree of transaction frequency. This move to high-frequency trading at the millisecond level, propelled by algorithmic strategies, has brought to the forefront short-term market reactions, like market impact, which were previously negligible in low-frequency trading scenarios. Such evolution necessitates a new framework for analyzing and developing algorithmic strategies in these rapidly evolving markets. Employing artificial markets stands out as a solution to this problem. This study aims to construct an artificial foreign exchange market referencing market microstructure theory, without relying on the assumption of information or technical traders. Furthermore, it endeavors to validate the model by replicating stylized facts, such as fat tails, which exhibit a higher degree of kurtosis in the return distribution than that predicted by normal distribution models. The validated artificial market model will be used to simulate market dynamics and algorithm strategies; its generated rates could also be applied to pricing and risk management for currency options and other foreign exchange derivatives. Moreover, this work explores the importance of order flow and the underlying factors of stylized facts within the artificial market model.

Dynamic social interactions and keystone species shape the diversity and stability of mixed-species biofilms – an example from dairy isolates

Identifying interspecies interactions in mixed-species biofilms is a key challenge in microbial ecology and is of paramount importance given that interactions govern community functionality and stability. We previously reported a bacterial four-species biofilm model comprising Stenotrophomonas rhizophila, Bacillus licheniformis, Microbacterium lacticum, and Calidifontibacter indicus that were isolated from the surface of a dairy pasteuriser after cleaning and disinfection. These bacteria produced 3.13-fold more biofilm mass compared to the sum of biofilm masses in monoculture. The present study confirms that the observed community synergy results from dynamic social interactions, encompassing commensalism, exploitation, and amensalism. M. lacticum appears to be the keystone species as it increased the growth of all other species that led to the synergy in biofilm mass. Interactions among the other three species (in the absence of M. lacticum) also contributed towards the synergy in biofilm mass. Biofilm inducing effects of bacterial cell-free-supernatants were observed for some combinations, revealing the nature of the observed synergy, and addition of additional species to dual-species combinations confirmed the presence of higher-order interactions within the biofilm community. Our findings provide understanding of bacterial interactions in biofilms which can be used as an interaction–mediated approach for cultivating, engineering, and designing synthetic bacterial communities.

Synthetic high-density lipoprotein (sHDL): a bioinspired nanotherapeutics for managing periapical bone inflammation

Apical periodontitis (AP) is a dental-driven condition caused by pathogens and their toxins infecting the inner portion of the tooth (i.e., dental pulp tissue), resulting in inflammation and apical bone resorption affecting 50% of the worldwide population, with more than 15 million root canals performed annually in the United States. Current treatment involves cleaning and decontaminating the infected tissue with chemo-mechanical approaches and materials introduced years ago, such as calcium hydroxide, zinc oxide–eugenol, or even formalin products. Here, we present, for the first time, a nanotherapeutics based on using synthetic high-density lipoprotein (sHDL) as an innovative and safe strategy to manage dental bone inflammation. sHDL application in concentrations ranging from 25 µg to 100 µg/mL decreases nuclear factor Kappa B (NF-κB) activation promoted by an inflammatory stimulus (lipopolysaccharide, LPS). Moreover, sHDL at 500 µg/mL concentration markedly decreases in vitro osteoclastogenesis (P < 0.001), and inhibits IL-1α (P = 0.027), TNF-α (P = 0.004), and IL-6 (P < 0.001) production in an inflammatory state. Notably, sHDL strongly dampens the Toll-Like Receptor signaling pathway facing LPS stimulation, mainly by downregulating at least 3-fold the pro-inflammatory genes, such as Il1b, Il1a, Il6, Ptgs2, and Tnf. In vivo, the lipoprotein nanoparticle applied after NaOCl reduced bone resorption volume to (1.3 ± 0.05) mm3 and attenuated the inflammatory reaction after treatment to (1 090 ± 184) cells compared to non-treated animals that had (2.9 ± 0.6) mm3 (P = 0.012 3) and (2 443 ± 931) cells (P = 0.004), thus highlighting its promising clinical potential as an alternative therapeutic for managing dental bone inflammation.

Expert consensus on the diagnosis and therapy of endo-periodontal lesions

Endo-periodontal lesions (EPLs) involve both the periodontium and pulp tissue and have complicated etiologies and pathogenic mechanisms, including unique anatomical and microbiological characteristics and multiple contributing factors. This etiological complexity leads to difficulties in determining patient prognosis, posing great challenges in clinical practice. Furthermore, EPL-affected teeth require multidisciplinary therapy, including periodontal therapy, endodontic therapy and others, but there is still much debate about the appropriate timing of periodontal therapy and root canal therapy. By compiling the most recent findings on the etiology, pathogenesis, clinical characteristics, diagnosis, therapy, and prognosis of EPL-affected teeth, this consensus sought to support clinicians in making the best possible treatment decisions based on both biological and clinical evidence.

Clinical practice recommendations for the diagnosis and management of X-linked hypophosphataemia

X-linked hypophosphataemia (XLH) is a rare metabolic bone disorder caused by pathogenic variants in the PHEX gene, which is predominantly expressed in osteoblasts, osteocytes and odontoblasts. XLH is characterized by increased synthesis of the bone-derived phosphaturic hormone fibroblast growth factor 23 (FGF23), which results in renal phosphate wasting with consecutive hypophosphataemia, rickets, osteomalacia, disproportionate short stature, oral manifestations, pseudofractures, craniosynostosis, enthesopathies and osteoarthritis. Patients with XLH should be provided with multidisciplinary care organized by a metabolic bone expert. Historically, these patients were treated with frequent doses of oral phosphate supplements and active vitamin D, which was of limited efficiency and associated with adverse effects. However, the management of XLH has evolved in the past few years owing to the availability of burosumab, a fully humanized monoclonal antibody that neutralizes circulating FGF23. Here, we provide updated clinical practice recommendations for the diagnosis and management of XLH to improve outcomes and quality of life in these patients.

Responses

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *