Curating transformation can strengthen adaptation and minimize losses and damages

Significant places, the city of Nimrud

Cities are vulnerable to climate change. They are particularly at risk from sea level rise, flooding, drought and heat waves2. As early as 2040 Africa and Asia will have an additional 2.29 million and 16.36 million people exposed to coastal flooding respectively1. This will impact coastal heritage with many cities at the coast losing part or all of their significant ‘places’22.

In 2016, ISIS destroyed almost 90% of the archeological remains of the ancient Mesopotamian city of Nimrud23. Although a casualty of conflict, not climate change, it presents a lesson in curating significant places, past and present, by recording their history and archeology, preserving their cultural attributes, and educating their communities and the wider public on their significance. This not only enables the re-presentation and valuation of what remains but also gives people agency over what is lost.

Nimrud, like other great ancient cities—Angkhor Wat, Teotihuacán, Machu Picchu—stood as a testament to remarkable human endeavor and creativity. To the Iraqi people, it evidenced the achievements of their nation’s past, while its ‘ancientness’ and authenticity added to its cultural value23. The destruction of Nimrud is on one level a catastrophe, but the city has been recorded, analyzed and interpreted, in academic journals, books, art, movies and fiction, while its material remains are housed in museums around the world. As such, even in its destruction its intrinsic cultural value and significance have not been lost. Moreover, its destruction offers an opportunity to undertake modern excavations24, which will provide new insights into how people living in agglomerated settlements negotiated urban planning, and such fundamentals as mobility, walkability, local self-sufficiency, gastronomy and healthy living9. New excavations would not have been possible had the extant remains not been destroyed. Far from being lost, its continued curation ensures its previous iterations are remembered and valued even while new excavations reveal more ancient aspects of the city and give it new value.

Traditional lifeways, hunting in the Arctic Circle

The planet is on track to warm by more than 2 °C above pre-industrial temperatures within 30 years and possibly by 3 °C towards the end of the century if we continue current greenhouse gas emissions1. In this scenario, transformational adaptation pathways will become both increasingly difficult and necessary, with low-income countries, marginalized communities, and some minority groups being at greater risk of reaching limits to adaptation and the potential for maladaptation21,25. The traditional lifeways of First Nations hunters and Arctic Indigenous communities are at the forefront of this challenge, being at risk of poor outcomes for both transformational and transformative adaptation.

Key elements for positive transformative adaptation include: (1) making rights and justice the target of adaptation, (2) acknowledging power relations, (3) embracing knowledge pluralism, (4) fostering bottom-up coalitions to strengthen local sources of adaptation, and (5) recognizing risks, trade-offs and unexpected outcomes21. Knowledge exchange between First Nations hunters and Arctic Indigenous communities is a heritage example of where these five key elements have been successfully put into practice with legislative commitment from the Canadian Government25.

In the Arctic Circle the loss of sea ice, which is classified as World Heritage by UNESCO, is impacting Indigenous (Inuit) traditional lifeways by limiting their ability to hunt seals and whales25. In response, knowledge exchange between First Nations hunters and Arctic Indigenous communities is transforming the ways in which Inuit hunt, which helps to preserve traditional ways of life and ways of remembering what has been lost. First Nations hunters from the Northwest Territories are building capacity and providing skills to Labrador Inuit related to moose harvesting. In exchange, Labrador Inuit are sharing their expertise in harvesting, processing, and use of ringed seals. As traditional sources of food become scarcer and as the ecological niche of moose moves north, new ways of hunting for Labrador Inuit will bring about positive transformative adaptation, engendering resilience and keeping alive ways of life, even as traditional modes of hunting are impeded by changing environments25,26.

Living heritage, Fa’a Samoa

Pacific island communities will experience considerable economic and non-economic losses and damages from climate change in the future. Recent research has shown that non-economic losses and damages amongst Pacific Island communities are understood, perceived, and experienced through the lens of intangible values, identity, and cultural landscapes4. A considerable challenge for climate change adaptation to losses and damages will be preserving the living heritage of Pacific Island communities. For Pacific Islanders, the land of their ancestral home is a sacred space. A plot of land is inhabited by the same family for generations and cannot be assessed in purely economic terms. Ancestors are buried within its boundaries, and these are believed to live on as the spiritual guardians who watch over the family and protect the land. Western perspectives of home ownership do not fully grasp the extent to which the loss of family land can directly contribute to the loss of Pacific Islander identity27. By drawing on the concept and praxis of curating transformation, Pacific Island communities can ensure that the loss of their homeland does not also entail the loss of their identity.

Increasingly, museums are playing a key role in the continuity of identity and social practice of Pacific Island peoples. The very real cultural damage associated with forced migration, an inevitable outcome of rising seas, is inspiring innovative exhibitions curated by Pacific Islanders. Interventions into museum programming, acquisitions, research and publication have reset the aims of these exhibitions away from ‘showing culture’ to ‘producing culture’27. In 2019, Te Papa Tongarewa Museum in Aotearoa New Zealand created a new exhibition space Te Taigo (‘nature’), where different aspects of climate change impacts on the lives of Pacific Islanders are presented. This people-centered exhibition space asks its audiences to take on the role of guardians, and by so doing, the exhibition situates itself and its audiences within the context of climate action (https://www.tepapa.govt.nz/te-taiao-nature-exhibition-new-benchmark-for-new-generation) giving agency to people and enabling participatory curation of change.

Heritage principles for curating transformation

Best practice in climate change adaptation includes meaningful participation of diverse groups in decision-making processes, the recognition that equitable power relations are key to successful outcomes, that the co-production of diverse knowledge offers greater legitimacy for adaptation solutions, that grassroots coalitions empower from the ground up, and that there will always be risks and unexpected outcomes21.

Curating transformation offers three further guiding principles from heritage conservation, the most important being the recognition that different kinds of value are intrinsic to successful adaptation outcomes. Identifying and understanding what is valued will determine what are considered intolerable, tolerable, and acceptable losses and damages3. Second is anticipatory recording of what is valued and making this equitably accessible via different media. Finally, learning encourages informed and active participation across different stakeholders. Experts should use their knowledge and skills to encourage and enable others to continuously and iteratively learn how best to respond to climate change28. There is also a need for language that informs dialog about loss that enables communities to describe and debate the process of loss and provide some structure to help people address what is an intractable state of change12.

Conclusion

Heritage practice provides a template for climate change adaptation that balances action to minimize losses and damages where such action is possible, and the management of unavoidable losses and damages where it is not. Curating transformation, as practiced in the heritage sector, provides three new guiding principles for advancing both transformational and transformative adaptation: (1) identifying what is valued, (2) ensuring it is recorded before it is lost, and (3) engaging with people about its significance to enable acceptance and ‘letting go’ in relation to what cannot be saved, while salvaging value for current and future generations3,27. Curating transformation provides a context in which new value can be created, communicated, and adopted through anticipation of and adaptation to future loss. Through recognition of both economic and non-economic values, curating transformation holds the potential to deliver adaptation outcomes that are both more positive and more pragmatic than those driven by conventional decision-making based on tangible assets and economic values. Further, it helps overcome the false dichotomy of ‘economic’ and ‘non-economic’ dimensions in research and policy through its ability to capture tangible and intangible heritage value29. Inclusive decision-making processes that recognize the diversity of perceptions and values relating to what is at risk address the needs and priorities of those who are most vulnerable and whose voices are often ignored. Curating transformation can reduce the risk of maladaptation that is inherent in preservation-based approaches that are unrealistic in the face of large climate change impacts.

Related Articles

Socially vulnerable communities face disproportionate exposure and susceptibility to U.S. wildfire and prescribed burn smoke

While air pollution from most U.S. sources has decreased, emissions from wildland fires have risen. Here, we use an integrated assessment model to estimate that wildfire and prescribed burn smoke caused $200 billion in health damages in 2017, associated with 20,000 premature deaths. Nearly half of this damage came from wildfires, predominantly in the West, with the remainder from prescribed burns, mostly in the Southeast. Our analysis reveals positive correlations between smoke exposure and various social vulnerability measures; however, when also considering smoke susceptibility, these disparities are systematically influenced by age. Senior citizens, who are disproportionately White, represented 16% of the population but incurred 75% of the damages. Nonetheless, within most age groups, Native American and Black communities experienced the greatest damages per capita. Our work highlights the extraordinary and disproportionate effects of the growing threat of fire smoke and calls for targeted, equitable policy solutions for a healthier future.

Comprehensive co-expression network reveals the fine-tuning of AsHSFA2c in balancing drought tolerance and growth in oat

Persistent activation of drought tolerance is detrimental to plant growth and development. However, the mechanism that balances plant drought tolerance and growth remains largely undetermined. Here, we constructed a comprehensive co-expression network comprising 84 transcriptome datasets associated with growth and drought tolerance in oats. Moreover, 84 functional modules and many candidate genes related to drought tolerance and growth were identified. A key candidate gene, AsHSFA2c was involved in fine-tuning the balance between drought tolerance and growth by inhibiting plant growth and positively regulating drought tolerance. Then, we determined AsDOF25 as an upstream positive regulator and AsAGO1 as the downstream target gene of AsHSFA2c. These results imply that the AsDOF25-AsHSFA2c-AsAGO1 module contributes to the balance between drought tolerance and growth in oats. Our findings and resources will facilitate the identification of key genes related to drought tolerance and further studies of the genetic basis underlying strong drought tolerance in oats.

Unequal roles of cities in the intercity healthcare system

Cities are increasingly interdependent regarding healthcare provision and demand. However, the intercity healthcare system (IHS) behind the nationwide patient mobility remains insufficiently understood. Here, leveraging human mobility big data, we reveal cities’ roles in providing and demanding quality healthcare within the IHS of China. We find that 8% of Chinese cities are national and regional hubs that address the healthcare shortage of cities deprived of quality healthcare, while 63% of the cities that are unnoticed compensate for migrant workers being denied healthcare rights in megacities. The IHS generates new structural inequalities in healthcare access exhibiting a Matthew effect. The few cities (12%) that are already rich in healthcare resources benefit more and can strengthen their advantages in providing healthcare to local populations (32% of China’s total population). The many cities (35%), while facing healthcare shortages, are further disadvantaged in ensuring adequate healthcare for their local populations (26% of China’s total population).

Coastal wetland resilience through local, regional and global conservation

Coastal wetlands, including tidal marshes, mangrove forests and tidal flats, support the livelihoods of millions of people. Understanding the resilience of coastal wetlands to the increasing number and intensity of anthropogenic threats (such as habitat conversion, pollution, fishing and climate change) can inform what conservation actions will be effective. In this Review, we synthesize anthropogenic threats to coastal wetlands and their resilience through the lens of scale. Over decades and centuries, anthropogenic threats have unfolded across local, regional and global scales, reducing both the extent and quality of coastal wetlands. The resilience of existing coastal wetlands is driven by their quality, which is modulated by both physical conditions (such as sediment supply) and ecological conditions (such as species interactions operating from local through to global scales). Protection and restoration efforts, however, are often localized and focus on the extent of coastal wetlands. The future of coastal wetlands will depend on an improved understanding of their resilience, and on society’s actions to enhance both their extent and quality across different scales.

High intensity perturbations induce an abrupt shift in soil microbial state

Soil microbial communities play a pivotal role in regulating ecosystem functioning. But they are increasingly being shaped by human-induced environmental change, including intense “pulse” perturbations, such as droughts, which are predicted to increase in frequency and intensity with climate change. While it is known that soil microbial communities are sensitive to such perturbations and that effects can be long-lasting, it remains untested whether there is a threshold in the intensity and frequency of perturbations that can trigger abrupt and persistent transitions in the taxonomic and functional characteristics of soil microbial communities. Here we demonstrate experimentally that intense pulses of drought equivalent to a 30-year drought event (<15% WHC) induce a major shift in the soil microbial community characterised by significantly altered bacterial and fungal community structures of reduced complexity and functionality. Moreover, the characteristics of this transformed microbial community persisted after returning soil to its previous moisture status. As a result, we found that drought had a strong legacy effect on bacterial community function, inducing an enhanced growth rate following subsequent drought. Abrupt transitions are widely documented in aquatic and terrestrial plant communities in response to human-induced perturbations. Our findings demonstrate that such transitions also occur in soil microbial communities in response to high intensity pulse perturbations, with potentially deleterious consequences for soil health.

Responses

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *