Speculating suitability of partial adrenalectomy for lateralized primary aldosteronism: With emphasis on partial and complete success as optimistic outcomes

Primary aldosteronism (PA), the most common cause of secondary hypertension, is characterized by excessive endogenous plasma aldosterone production in the presence of suppressed plasma renin activity (PRA) [1, 2]. The treatment of choice for a lateralized PA is unilateral adrenalectomy (surgical removal of the affected adrenal gland), which aims to resolve excess aldosterone production and, subsequently, alleviate hypertension; potentially allowing PA patients to discontinue (all) antihypertensive medications [3].

Traditionally, total adrenalectomy (complete removal of the affected unilateral adrenal gland) was the standard approach. However, recent studies have explored the feasibility and potential benefits of a partial adrenalectomy, which involves removing only the part of the adrenal gland that contains the tumoral mass, while preserving the rest of the grossly normal-looking gland. By sparing a portion of the adrenal gland, PA patients might be at a lower risk of developing future adrenal insufficiency, which could be a concern after total adrenalectomy [4]. Partial adrenalectomy is often considered in cases where the adrenal tumor is small, likely benign, and not cancerous [5], or in cases of simultaneous or metachronous bilateral adrenal tumors. However, in some PA cases, especially those involving multiple aldosterone-producing micronodules/nodules (mAPM/mAPN), partial adrenalectomy cannot completely remove the origins of all excessive aldosterone-producing tissues, and thus might be unable to resolve hypertension, and defeat the initial purpose of the surgery [6]. There is a possibility that the main tumoral mass shown in imaging studies is either non-functional (an incidentaloma) or only partially functional, with concurrent mAPM/mAPN in the surrounding healthy-looking adrenal gland still leading to residual hypertension [7,8,9,10].

Cytochrome P450 11B2 (CYP11B2), also known as aldosterone synthase, is essential in aldosterone synthesis and plays an important role in the pathogenesis of PA [11]. By using immunochemistry with specific monoclonal antibodies targeting CYP11B2, cells that synthesize aldosterone in the adrenal zona glomerulosa can be identified [12]. The expression of CYP11B2 is typically regulated by angiotensin II, however, autonomous CYP11B2 expression is seen in aldosterone-producing adenomas (APA), aldosterone-producing nodules (APN) or mPAM/mAPN, or even aldosterone-producing diffuse hyperplasia (APDH), which could possibly be due to somatic mutations of certain potassium or calcium channel, with mutations of the gene encoding the potassium inwardly rectifying channel, subfamily J, member 5 (KCNJ5) being the most common [13,14,15,16,17]. Whereas CYP11B1, the gene encoding 11-beta-hydroxylase, is important in cortisol synthesis. Studies revealed lower CYP11B1 and higher CYP11B2 expression in adrenal adenomas in PA than those in Cushing’s syndrome [18]. CYP11B2 immunohistochemical staining is a robust method for the histopathological diagnosis and classification of primary aldosteronism (HISTALDO; histopathology of PA) [19].

This study aims to determine the proportion of classical (black group + grey group) and non-classical (white group) lateralized PA, the percentage of co-existing mAPM/mAPN in clinically diagnosed lateralized PA, and the clinical and biochemical outcomes after undergoing a total adrenalectomy in each groups, according to the PA surgical outcomes criteria (PASO) [20, 21].

This study was conducted by investigators from the TAIPAI (Taiwan Primary Aldosteronism Investigation) study group via using a prospective collection of patients and specimens with PA.

From February 1999 to August 2018, patients with hypertension and an image-identifiable adrenal nodule/adenoma who underwent unilateral laparoscopic adrenalectomy were enrolled. The diagnosis of PA was made via standardized aldosterone/renin ratio screening test and confirmatory tests, including the saline infusion test or captopril test [22]. Adrenal venous sampling (AVS) was performed to assure its functional unilateral lateralization. APA is further confirmed after adrenalectomy: pathologically proven a CYP11B2 adenoma or aldosterone-producing cell clusters at immunohistochemistry after adrenalectomy, and subsequent emergence of biochemical correction. Standard H&E staining and immunohistochemistry staining using a mouse monoclonal antibody for CYP11B2 were analyzed retrospectively.

The lateralization index (LI) of AVS is defined as the ratio of the aldosterone/cortisol concentration on the dominant side to that on the contralateral side. Successful AVS is defined as a selectivity index (SI) value ≥ 2.0 bilaterally; in which SI is defined as the ratio of the sampled cortisol concentration of each adrenal vein to that of the peripheral vein without the stimulation of cosyntropin. After confirming successful bilateral AVS, confirmative lateralization of the PA was determined by an LI value ≥ 2.0.

The excised adrenal specimens were categorized into three groups according to the HISTALDO criteria, including: “black group” for solitary APA or dominant APN with strong positive CYP11B2 staining in the tumor mass only, “grey group” for cases with both the main tumor and mAPM/mAPN in the surrounding H&E normal-looking adrenal tissues showing positive CYP11B2 staining; and “white group” for the main tumor with negative CYP11B2 staining (incidentaloma) and surrounding mAPM/mAPN with positive CYP11B2 staining. The PA patients in the black and grey groups form the “classical” lateralized PA patients, and the PA patients in the white groups consist of the “non-classical” lateralized PA patients [8].

Clinical and biochemical outcomes were defined based on the PASO consensus, with at least 2 post-adrenalectomy follow-up visits. “Complete clinical success” was defined according to the PASO criteria of normalized blood pressure without any antihypertensive agents after adrenalectomy. “Complete biochemical success” was defined as normalized aldosterone-renin ratio (ARR) and normalized potassium level after adrenalectomy. “Partial clinical success” was defined according to the PASO criteria of better blood pressure control with still some antihypertensive agents needed after adrenalectomy [20]. The existence of a KCNJ5 somatic mutation was checked with Sanger or next-generation sequencing technique from the excised adenomas/nodules or CYP11B2-positive adrenal tissues.

Statistical analysis

All statistical analyses were tabulated and analyzed by Stata version 16 for Windows® (Stata Corp, College Station, TX, USA). The Pearson’s chi‑square test and Fisher’s exact test were used to evaluate the association between categorical variables, and the ANOVA test was applied to compare the continuous variables. The changes of the preoperative and postoperative blood pressure were analyzed using paired t-test. All tests were two-sided with p < 0.05 considered statistically significant. Post-hoc test was performed with Bonferonni correction.

A total of 445 patients who underwent unilateral laparoscopic adrenalectomy were enrolled. Amongst them, 390 patients were diagnosed with lateralized PA. Among the 390 lateralized PA patients, 174 (44.6%) were men and 216 (55.4%) were women. The mean age was 48.4, 50.6, and 54.2 years old in the black, grey, and white groups, respectively. There was no significance regarding gender, mean body weight, mean body height, mean body mass index (BMI), mean waist line, mean buttocks width, mean blood pressure, duration of hypertension, Charlson comorbidity index, maximum diameter of the adrenal nodule, AVS LI, nor contralateral suppression during adrenal venous sampling among the three groups. The number of antihypertensive agents used preoperatively and the preoperative ARR were comparable between groups (Table 1). The histopathological features and immunohistochemistry findings of the black group (solitary APA or a dominant APN with positive CYP11B2 staining), grey group (both the main tumor and mAPM/mAPN showing positive CYP11B2 staining), and white group (main tumor with negative CYP11B2 staining and mAPM/mAPN with positive CYP11B2 staining) are shown in Fig. 1. The resected adrenal glands were categorized into three groups according to the HISTALDO criteria: 63 (30.73%) in the black group, 79 (38.54%) in the grey group, 63 (30.73%) in the white group; whereas 185 adrenal glands/tumors were too challenging to be classified due to limited specimens.

Histopathological and immunohistochemistry (CYP11B2) features of the black (solitary APA or dominant APN with strong positive CYP11B2 staining in the tumor mass only), grey (both the main tumoral mass and mAPM/mAPN in the surrounding H&E normal-looking adrenal tissues showing positive CYP11B2 staining), and white (main tumor with negative CYP11B2 staining (incidentaloma) and surrounding mAPM/mAPN with positive CYP11B2 staining) groups

Full size image

The overall complete clinical success rate was 200/390 (51.28%) in all patients with lateralized PA, with the PA patients of the black group having the highest complete clinical success rate (41/63 [65.08%]), when compared to that of the grey (40/79 [50.63%]) or white group (17/63 [26.98%]), as shown in Table 2 (p < 0.0001). The overall partial clinical success rate was 38.54% in lateralized PA patients, with 28.57% in the black group, 34.18% in the grey group, and 53.97% in the white group. There was no statistically significant difference in the biochemical outcomes between the three groups, with a complete biochemical success rate of 87.30%, 82.28%, and 80.95%, respectively (p = 0.595) (Table 3).

Among the patients with a complete clinical or complete biochemical success, more PA patients in the black group had KCNJ5 mutation (p < 0.0001). Furthermore, in the patients with absent clinical success after undergoing a total adrenalectomy, KCNJ5 mutation was noted in 2/4 patients in the black group, 4/12 patients in the grey group, and 0/12 patients in the white group (Tables 2 and 3).

Patients in all groups had a comparable preoperative blood pressure. Follow up mean blood pressures at the post-total adrenalectomy 6th and 12th months significantly decreased when compared to the preoperative blood pressures. In addition, the PA patients in the grey and white groups seem to have less and slower recovery of their hypertension after undergoing a unilateral adrenalectomy (Tables 4 and 5).

The proportion of classical and non-classical and the percentage of co-existing mAPM/mAPN in clinically diagnosed lateralized PA are reported in this study. In a study of patients diagnosed with a single APA, Jeschke et al. reported successful treatment of hypertension and hyperaldosteronism with low complication rate [5]. However, our results show that, among the patients with lateralized PA, only 63 (30.73%) of the resected adrenal glands contained solitary APA or a dominant APN with positive CYP11B2 staining. Despite previous study reporting successful treatment of hypertension following resection of the involved tumor, our results revealed that, if only partial adrenalectomy were performed among these lateralized PA patients, we could completely remove the aldosterone-producing part among the PA patients in the black group, while leaving the aldosterone-producing parts of those (about 69.3%) in the other two groups in the remaining ipsilateral adrenal gland. Such a selective surgical approach could very likely yield a suboptimal treatment success rate in treating lateralized PA, and thus the majority of lateralized PA patients may not benefit after receiving a partial adrenalectomy.

Kitamoto et al. reported their experience using segmental selective AVS to identify the intra-adrenal aldosterone activity [23]. If the classical type (black group) is confirmed using segmental adrenal tributary sampling, partial adrenalectomy might potentially be acceptable. However, several factors, such as variable accompanying cortisol levels, may affect the data interpretation and lead to possible underdiagnoses of functioning mAPN/mAPM [24].

For inoperable patients, alternative ablative treatments may be considered, including radiofrequency ablation (RFA), cryoablation, and microwave ablation [25,26,27,28]. Among these methods, RFA is the most commonly used for adrenal tumors due to its small ablation zone and excellent clinical and biochemical outcomes for functional benign adrenal tumors, such as APA, cortisol-secreting adenomas, and pheochromocytomas [29]. Common complications include hypertensive crisis, bleeding, infection, bowel injury, pneumothorax, and adrenal insufficiency. Both RFA and partial adrenalectomy can be useful in avoiding adrenal insufficiency. However, with the theory of HISTALDO having the possibilities of co-existing mAPM/mAPN that could still secrete excess plasma aldosterone, even if the visible tumoral mass is well treated with an ablation therapy, it still carries the potential risk of incomplete treatment, like the case for partial adrenalectomy. Further prospective, randomized studies are needed to compare the clinical and biochemical success rates and remaining adrenal function outcomes of RFA or partial adrenalectomy versus unilateral total adrenalectomy if such therapies would like to be applied to all lateralized PA patients [26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34].

In our study, biochemical success rates were comparable across the three groups, but complete clinical success rates were lower in the grey and white groups. The comparable biochemical success rates among the HISTALDO groups confirmed the accuracy of our lateralized PA diagnosis. However, patients in the grey and white groups seem to have less and slower recovery of their clinical outcomes, despite having undergo unilateral total adrenalectomy rather than partial adrenalectomy. Factors such as age, comorbidities, and longer duration of hypertension may contribute to poorer clinical outcomes after unilateral adrenalectomy for the lateralized PA patients. Notably, patients in the black group were significantly younger than those in the other two groups (p = 0.0125), as shown in Table 1. While hypertension duration appeared longer in the grey and white groups, this difference was not statistically significant. Contralateral suppression during AVS was observed in three patients in the black group, two in the grey group, and none in the white group. All three black group patients achieved complete clinical and biochemical success, whereas one grey group patient achieved complete clinical success and the other achieved partial clinical success. These differences may explain why the complete clinical success rates were lower in the grey and white groups, and why the grey and white groups seem to have less and slower recovery of their clinical outcomes, despite having undergo unilateral total adrenalectomy. However, more research is needed for further clarification.

Furthermore, rarely did the literature discuss PA patients with PASO partial clinical success actually still benefit from unilateral adrenalectomy (better controlled blood pressure, fewer antihypertensive medications; even though not normotensive without medications; according to the definition of partial clinical success), and thus could still be considered as an “optimistic outcome” after unilateral adrenalectomy for those lateralized PA patients. Despite the complete clinical success being better achieved in the black group, our results showed that lateralized PA patients in all groups have a combo clinical and biochemical optimistic outcomes rates (rates of complete success plus partial success) above 80% after undergoing unilateral adrenalectomy; justifying the benefits of unilateral total adrenalectomy for lateralized PA patients. But if only partial adrenalectomy (tumorectomy) were performed for lateralized PA patients of the grey and white groups, the mAPM/mAPN or APDH that secrete excess aldosterone would not be removed, then the optimistic outcomes in these PA patients would not be observed as currently seen. Thus, we conclude that in clinically lateralized PA patients, no matter which group they are in the HISTALDO classification, they would benefit from unilateral total adrenalectomy (no matter either clinical or biochemical outcomes are concerned).

It is known that mutations in the KCNJ5 gene are associated with APA, and are the most frequently known alterations in patients with PA [35]. However, our results showed that having a positive KCNJ5 mutation does not absolutely assure surgical success, even in the black (3.17% clinical failure and 1.59% biochemical failure) or grey group (5.06% clinical failure and 5.06% biochemical failure) of the lateralized PA patients.

This study has limitations. First, there were 185 lateralized PA specimens technically too challenging to be classified to a specific HISTALDO group, primarily due to inadequate tissue sampling. This issue arose because, in the past, only our specialized research lab conducted CYP11B2 immunohistochemical staining. Eventually, the pathology department in our hospital adopted it as a routine procedure for all clinically diagnosed PA adrenal specimens. Furthermore, in the early years of our TAIPAI cohort, either only the tumoral parts were collected for research, or the specimens included just the tumor and a small amount of adjacent normal-appearing adrenal tissue. As a result, we could not classify these 185 patients in the final analysis. However, if the distribution of HISTALDO classifications among these patients is consistent, we hypothesize that the proportions across groups should be similar. Second, only the KCNJ5 gene was analyzed in our study. We found that having a positive KCNJ5 mutation does not necessarily guarantee surgical success. This observational cohort requires further evaluation to clarify its clinical and pathophysiological significance.

Perspective of Asia

While the presence of a KCNJ5 somatic mutation has been identified as an independent predictor of hypertension remission following unilateral adrenalectomy in patients with lateralized PA, its prevalence differs between Asian and European populations [35,36,37,38]. Furthermore, our findings suggest that having a positive KCNJ5 mutation does not guarantee surgical success. Therefore, further studies are needed to confirm the prognostic value of KCNJ5 mutations in predicting hypertension remission after adrenalectomy for lateralized PA in other ethnic groups.

Our results show that partial adrenalectomy for lateralized PA patients may potentially lead to a significantly lower treatment success rate, no matter the criteria of success is considered as “complete success only” or “both complete and partial success”. Thus, based on reasonable inferences from the pathological analysis results using the well-defined HISTALDO classification—which clearly identifies the functionally active aldosterone-producing components of the diseased adrenal gland—we speculate that unilateral partial adrenalectomy is not a good surgical option for the majority of lateralized PA patients. Furthermore, patients in all groups demonstrate a clinical and biochemical “optimistic outcomes” rate above 80% (considering complete success plus partial success as optimistic outcomes). Therefore, we conclude that in clinically lateralized PA patients, no matter which group they are in the HISTALDO classification, they would benefit from unilateral total adrenalectomy. In addition, having a positive KCNJ5 mutation does not assure surgical success. All these observations require further, fully prospective evaluation to elucidate its clinical and pathophysiological significance.